|
|
|
New Member
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 3/25/2010 1:05:21 PM
Posts: 84,
Visits: 197
|
|
I have (my mom's) three fantails, and right now they are temporarily in a 10g tank because my mom is moving. She also wants to get two black moors and I told her, "I gotta buy you a 36g tank at least."
My mom: 
Anyway...my best friend had asked me a question: "Can I keep my goldfish with tropical fish."
I just wanted to make a point that I don't advise anyone to keep goldfish with tropical fish at all. Two main points on this matter:
1) Goldfish are cold water fish. They don't do well in the higher temperature ranges (80f and above) for long sustained time periods. That could be fatal to them. Room temperature is adequate for these beautiful fish.
2) Goldfish are in the carp family...and they put out a LOT of waste. The amount of waste these fish put out can kill a lot of tropical fish quickly. And also like carp, goldfish can tolerate much more harsher conditions as compared to tropical fish.
I just wanted to voice these two points. If I am incorrect, or if I omitted any information by accident. Please drop it under this post!
|
|
|
|
|
Fish Moderator
Group: Moderators
Last Login: Today @ 5:43:59 PM
Posts: 3,710,
Visits: 9,278
|
|
are you talking about a 36g for just the two black moors or for all five fish together? Because if you're talking about all five goldfish, you'll need more like a 55-60g tank to properly house them.
About the rest, you are absolutely correct.
55 gallon
Little Bean - lionhead
Baby - lionhead/ryukin cross
Westie - lionhead/ryukin cross
Speedy Rodriguez - oranda
planted 29 gallon
6 red eye tetras
6 cherry barbs
2 cardinal tetras
4 neon tetras
8 albino cories
3 male guppies
|
|
|
|
|
Fishkeeping GURU
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 2/23/2011 6:10:41 AM
Posts: 12,694,
Visits: 6,330
|
|
You are correct. Also, tropicals and coolwater fish have different slime coats. What a goldfish carries harmlessly may wipe out a tank full of tropical in no time (and vice versa).
And as for tank size, I'm with Princessotfu.
.
|
|
|
|
|
New Member
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 3/25/2010 1:05:21 PM
Posts: 84,
Visits: 197
|
|
Okay cool!! Thanks for the info!! 60g...mom is gonna be REALLY happy now...
|
|
|
|
|
Average Member
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 8/21/2011 7:52:03 AM
Posts: 655,
Visits: 973
|
|
you are COMPLETELY correct on both situations, good. so some people say 10 gallons per goldfish but that is really following the 1 inch per gallon but goldies really need 2 in per gallon. just wanted to make a point of that.
29 gal: 2 mollies, >15 guppy fry, >10 molly fry, 1 farlowella cat
20 gal: 2 pearl gouramis, 7 cherry barbs, 1 female crowntail betta, 6 female guppies, 1 albino bristlenose pleco, 1 bumblebee catfish
10 gal: 2 black kuhli loaches, 11 male guppies
10 gal: >15 guppy fry, 1 rubberlip pleco, 1 nerite snail
5 gal: 1 celestial pearl danio, 1 male 1 female guppy, 1 nerite snail
2.5 gal: 1 male crowntail betta
Pond: some sunfish, some flagfish
Container Pond (20g): least killies
|
|
|
|
|
Average Member
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 7/17/2009 2:37:07 PM
Posts: 965,
Visits: 1,282
|
|
lilcherna (8/31/2007)
you are COMPLETELY correct on both situations, good. so some people say 10 gallons per goldfish but that is really following the 1 inch per gallon but goldies really need 2 in per gallon. just wanted to make a point of that. I'm not quite sure I understand this logic. How is 10 gallons per goldfish following the 1 gallon per inch rule? And what size is this goldfish in the 10 gallon tank, 1 inch, two inches, three, ten?
~M Every year of my life I grow more convinced that it is wisest and best to fix our attention on the beautiful and the good, and dwell as little as possible on the evil and the false." ~ Richard Cecil
|
|
|
|
|
New Member
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 10/20/2007 7:11:48 AM
Posts: 54,
Visits: 54
|
|
| Ok Im going to get stoned here *looks for cover. I've kept Goldfish (Ryukins) w/ Angels for years. I keep the tank at a "Nice" 70 degrees and the PH around a high 7.8 ( I use baking soda. Sorry for showing my age lol ) The Goldfish keep the Angel breeding down to a few babies at a time. Until I want a full brood them I put the Angel parents in another tank. As for the Extrea bio load I use a Large Boiwheel and 1 Canaster filter and do water changes every 2 weeks. Love my phython !! I haven't lost an "Adult" fish in sometime. And I add "greens" about once a week to the tank.
"Another Day Another Goldfish Saved "
|
|
|
|
|
Fishkeeping GURU
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 2/23/2011 6:10:41 AM
Posts: 12,694,
Visits: 6,330
|
|
It can be done, but it presents a number of risks that outweigh the benefits. Just keeping a separate tank of adequate size for the goldfish is the best way to go.
.
|
|
|
|
|
New Member
Group: Forum Members
Last Login: 3/25/2010 1:05:21 PM
Posts: 84,
Visits: 197
|
|
I agree with you Hailey...the risk is more than the reward in that case. I prefer to keep goldfish separate from tropical fish.
Oh and on another note...two snails popped into the goldfish tank last week, so I left them to help keep the algae under control. But I came back yesterday and I saw empty shells. I feed goldfish twice a day with flakes and once to twice a week with bloodworms (they love them). But I didn't know that goldfish actually ate snails...
I guess they wanted a midnight snack...on the half-shell.
|
|
|
|
|
Fish Moderator
Group: Moderators
Last Login: Today @ 5:43:59 PM
Posts: 3,710,
Visits: 9,278
|
|
goldfish food rules:
1. I will eat all the food as fast as possible, regardless of the effects of gulping large air bubbles.
2. I will stare at you ALL day begging for food. And if you put more in, I will eat it, see #1.
3. If it is small enough to fit in my mouth, I will attempt to eat it.
4. If it is too big for my mouth, I will probably attempt to eat it anyway.
5. If it is exactly the size of my throat, I will continue to keep trying to eat it, no matter how many times it gets stuck.
6. If it is green, I will attempt to eat it.
7. If it has a shell, I will eat the shell too. If I can't, I will find a way to get the food out of the shell.
8. If it has tasty appendages, I will bite them off.
9. If I don't know what it is, I"ll try to eat it, just on the off chance.
10. If I'm not supposed to eat it, I will eat it. Especially if you spent lots of money on it.
55 gallon
Little Bean - lionhead
Baby - lionhead/ryukin cross
Westie - lionhead/ryukin cross
Speedy Rodriguez - oranda
planted 29 gallon
6 red eye tetras
6 cherry barbs
2 cardinal tetras
4 neon tetras
8 albino cories
3 male guppies
|
|
|
|